Main Contractor Successfully Defends £500,000 Defects Adjudication

Reducing a complex claim concerning 22 categories of alleged defects to £13,000

Holmes & Hills' construction solicitors acted for a main contractor in defending an adjudication seeking approximately £500,000 in damages for alleged defects in a bespoke new-build property.

A substantial and complex defects claim

The claim concerned 22 separate categories of alleged defects, several of which contained multiple individual issues. The Referral Notice was supported by more than 1,400 pages of appendices and extensive technical evidence.

The adjudication proceeded through a Response, Reply, Rejoinder and Surrejoinder over an extended 42-day timetable spanning the Christmas and New Year period.

Defending the adjudication

The case involved a wide range of legal, factual and technical issues. These included whether:

  • the employers had failed to mitigate their losses by refusing the main contractor access to undertake remedial works, including during the Covid pandemic;
  • the employers had frustrated attempts to investigate the alleged defects and agree suitable remedial works by preventing their Contract Administrator and Quantity Surveyor from continuing discussions with the main contractor;
  • particular issues resulted from the main contractor's workmanship or from designs provided by others; and
  • the employers could recover the consequential losses claimed, including legal costs relating to previously threatened litigation.

The outcome

Despite the scale of the claim and the compressed timetable, Holmes & Hills secured a successful outcome for the main contractor immediately before the Christmas shutdown.

The adjudicator decided that the main contractor should pay £13,000 in respect of minor defects, against an overall claim of approximately £500,000.

Why the case matters

A referring party will often have spent weeks or months preparing a defects claim before serving its Notice of Adjudication. The responding party may then have only days to assemble the project records, obtain expert evidence and answer a substantial technical case.

A clear division between workmanship, design responsibility, causation and the reasonable cost of remedial works can materially reduce the value of a defects claim. Early preservation of the project records and prompt expert input are particularly important.

Get expert construction adjudication advice

If you have received a Notice of Adjudication concerning alleged defects, obtain specialist advice immediately so that the evidence and response strategy can be put in place within the adjudication timetable.

Get specialist construction law advice

Call us on 01206 593933 today to speak with one of our construction law solicitors. Or complete the form below.

Receive the latest legal updates

Get important legal updates, news and opinion sent to you straight from our solicitors.
Sign Up

A Mackman Group collaboration - market research by Mackman Research | website design by Mackman

linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram